I´ll do it like one against the other since to me itm it seems interesting at least.
I looked them up both on the movie data base Imdb typically enough but not to bias (favor) one over the other one meanwhile i ask this forum section which one of them that was the better one i´ll refrain from telling the ratings from there.

I just recently saw Take Shelter and yeah, it´s worth seeing for several reasons, i´ll still just give it a 3/5 score but that´s me being extremely cheap with any score higher than what´s relatively out there to watch. If not being in "cheap mode" i´ll give it a 4/5 then.

Clearly a thread then for those that saw both movies. Fun fact: Almost 10 times more reviews for the movie Sixth Sense.

Finally why do i compare these movies out of all that´s out there? Kind of hard to tell but they seem similar in their setup as movies and what would be an interesting thing to see which one of the both that here would gather the most votes, likes.

Sixth Sense trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-ZP95NF_Wk
Take Shelter trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUraDx3oFVg